The Decline of Facebook Civilization, Part 2

Pile of Facebook Logos

We lived through the first wave of the crisis that is the decline of Facebook reach for brand posts. “Reachpocalypse” as Jay Baer called it here. We all freaked out as we watched our posts barely reach any of our “Like” audience. We cursed Facebook in posts, blogs, Tweets, etc. You remember that right? Well, get ready to do it all over again…

Jay Baer Presenting

Facebook announced that they will be reducing promotional page posts on news feeds. This is likely going to bring many brands’ posts down to zero reach. They say there are certain criteria that make a post “too promotional.” These criteria push people to buy or enter a contest with no context or reusing exact ad copy. This is the beginning of the end of free posting for brands…or the decline of Facebook. We’re going to have to pay for ads now to get our content seen.

Facebook is saying this is what its users want. But, if they asked users what they want, they’d probably say they want less bad posts. Bad posts can come from brands or friends/family (yes, thank you for showing yet another photo of what you’re about to eat).

Facebook Thumbs Down

Taking off my marketing hat for a minute, because I’m a user too, I don’t mind seeing posts from brands I like. In fact, I like seeing their posts much more than any Facebook ads. Do I like it better when they’re useful and/or fun rather than salesy? Of course. Are there brands that I’ve liked on Facebook that I don’t want to see their posts? Again, yes. Can’t I just unlike the brands that I don’t want to see content from? Yes, but laziness and/or procrastination usually take hold here.

What I’d like as a user is for Facebook to give me (and all us) control over what we see. If I like a brand, have something pop up that I click “yes” or “no” on if I want to see posts from the brand in my newsfeed. Then, give brands visibility into who clicks “no”. That info would be very valuable to a brand. Imagine if you could have a list of those who liked your brand but opted out of receiving your posts! (Looks like I put my marketing hat back on a couple of sentences ago.)   

Computer Keyboard with Social Media Buttons

But let’s face it…that’s not happening. But this further decline is. There is one potential benefit that may come from it. While a lot of the Facebook content from brands is good, there’s an awful lot that isn’t. A lot of companies post content for the sake of posting content.

If we all have to pay for what we want to post, we’re going to think more about what we put out there. Gone will be the “Oh crap, it’s 3pm and I still haven’t posted anything today!” Paying for ads forces brands to create their Facebook strategy. We need to make sure each post sticks to that strategy. You don’t want to pay for an ad that doesn’t get you closer to your goals. So, user feeds may be de-cluttered of crappy content (from brands…not much you can do about the friend that always posts their food photos). Win-win, I say…except for the paying for the ad part.

Joe Pulizzi Presenting at Content Marketing World

We all knew this was coming. And, it won’t stop with Facebook. Guess who owns Instagram? You’ve already heard the rumors that Twitter will be implementing algorithms to their feed. Just go down the line of your favorite social media platforms. There are no different solutions than there were when the decline first started. See Jay Baer’s article that I referenced earlier for his four options. And, as Joe Pulizzi has said many times: Stop building your branded content on rented land!

How much has the Facebook decline effected you so far? What have you done to compensate? What do you plan to do in the future? Please discuss in the comments below.

Thanks for reading and if you like this post, please share it with your marketing friends!

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *